I think the reason I love graduation wreckage so much is all that rich, fortified irony.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9d003/9d003fbf038094e7614342a714f2f1c66e936a41" alt=""
C'mon. It doesn't get a whole lot better than this.
As we all know, it's usually the "congratulations" that gets wrecked. Still, there are plenty of other options if a Wreckerator wants to mix it up a little:
In a class all its own.
Uh-oh. Looks like someone forgot to bring their "A" game.
Here's one for a competition between rival labeling companies:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af272/af272ddeb2c1ac15809a647269651db429153a9c" alt=""
[dramatic announcer voice] "Live! From Hollywood! It's Class off, two thousand ten!'"
One thing you've really got to hand to home-schooling:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/94ee1/94ee1654cd38cd48163237738fe3c9c929733051" alt=""
The grad ceremonies are
quick. I bet they're always first in line at Olive Garden.
And to really go the extra mile, some Wreckerators will throw in a fuzzy green image of someone else's graduation photo:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/803b1/803b146cce0d87c8555ba6500d5d3f9e5bbfaa70" alt=""
Yep, this was sitting out for sale with all the other "generic" graduation cakes. Putting aside the "Gjraduates" issue, it really sends a nice message, don't you think?
"Here's your cake. We thought this guy kind of looked like you."
"But...I'm Asian."
"Yes, well..."
"And a girl."
"He has your smile."
Many thanks to Sarah J., Kristin L., Sarah B., Amy S., Travis, & Julie O.:
This isn't them.